Backwardation

Image: Moneybestpal.com

Main Findings

• Backwardation is a phenomenon observed in commodity futures markets where the spot price of a commodity exceeds the futures price.
• Backwardation typically occurs due to short-term supply shortages, heightened demand, or immediate delivery requirements.

Backwardation is a term used in financial markets, particularly in commodity futures markets, to describe a situation where the spot price of a commodity is higher than the futures price for the same commodity. 

In other words, backwardation occurs when the future price of a commodity is lower than its current price. This phenomenon is often associated with short-term supply shortages, heightened demand, or immediate delivery requirements.

In backwardation, market participants are willing to pay a premium for immediate access to the commodity, resulting in higher spot prices relative to futures prices. 

This creates an upward-sloping futures curve, where prices decline as the delivery date approaches. Backwardation is the opposite of contango, where future prices are higher than spot prices, indicating expectations of future supply increases or decreased demand.

Why Backwardation Occurs

Backwardation typically occurs due to various factors influencing supply and demand dynamics in commodity markets:

Supply Shortages

Backwardation may arise when there are short-term disruptions or constraints in commodity supply, such as adverse weather conditions, production bottlenecks, or geopolitical tensions. Supply shortages can lead to immediate demand for available inventory, driving up spot prices relative to futures prices.

Heightened Demand

Increased demand for a commodity, either due to seasonal factors, unexpected consumption patterns, or speculative activities, can contribute to backwardation. When demand outpaces available supply, buyers may be willing to pay a premium for immediate delivery, exerting upward pressure on spot prices.

Storage Costs

In some cases, backwardation may reflect the cost of storing the physical commodity until the delivery date. If storage costs exceed the carrying costs embedded in futures prices, market participants may prefer immediate consumption or delivery, leading to backwardation.

Interest Rates

Backwardation can also be influenced by interest rates and financing costs. If the cost of financing inventory or holding futures contracts exceeds the benefits of carrying the commodity to a future date, backwardation may occur as market participants prefer immediate transactions over future commitments.

Formula for Calculating Backwardation

Backwardation is typically expressed as the difference between the spot price and the futures price of a commodity. The formula for calculating backwardation is as follows:

Backwardation = Spot Price - Futures Price

Where:

• Spot Price: The current market price of the commodity.
• Futures Price: The price at which the commodity can be bought or sold for delivery at a specified future date.

The resulting backwardation value represents the premium or discount of the spot price relative to the futures price. A positive backwardation value indicates that the spot price is higher than the futures price, signaling backwardation in the market.

How to Calculate Backwardation

Calculating backwardation involves obtaining spot and futures prices for the same commodity and subtracting the futures price from the spot price. Here's a step-by-step guide on how to calculate backwardation:

1. Obtain Spot Price

Determine the current spot price of the commodity by referring to real-time market data from commodity exchanges, financial news sources, or online trading platforms. The spot price represents the prevailing market price for immediate delivery or settlement of the commodity.

2. Identify Futures Price

Obtain the futures price for the same commodity by referencing futures contracts traded on commodity exchanges. Futures prices are quoted for standardized contracts with specified delivery dates in the future, reflecting market expectations of future supply and demand dynamics.

3. Calculate Backwardation

Subtract the futures price from the spot price to determine the backwardation value. The formula for calculating backwardation is:

Backwardation = Spot Price - Futures Price

4. Interpret Results

Analyze the calculated backwardation value to assess the relationship between spot and futures prices. A positive backwardation value indicates that the spot price is higher than the futures price, suggesting backwardation in the market.

Conversely, a negative backwardation value would indicate contango, where futures prices exceed spot prices.

By following these steps and performing the necessary calculations, traders, investors, and market participants can monitor backwardation trends in commodity markets and make informed decisions based on their market outlook and trading strategies.

Examples

Example 1: Crude Oil Backwardation

Scenario

During periods of geopolitical instability or supply disruptions, the crude oil market may experience backwardation. Suppose there is a sudden disruption in oil production from a major oil-producing region due to political unrest. 

This disruption leads to concerns about immediate supply shortages and prompts market participants to bid up spot prices for immediate delivery.

Calculation

If the spot price of crude oil is $70 per barrel, while the futures price for delivery in three months is $65 per barrel, the backwardation would be calculated as follows:

Backwardation = Spot Price - Futures Price

Backwardation = $70 - $65

Backwardation = $5 per barrel

Outcome

In this scenario, the backwardation of $5 per barrel indicates that the spot price is $5 higher than the futures price, reflecting market expectations of short-term supply shortages and heightened demand for immediate delivery.

Example 2: Gold Backwardation

Scenario

Gold is often considered a safe-haven asset, especially during times of economic uncertainty or market volatility. Suppose there is a sudden spike in geopolitical tensions, leading to increased demand for gold as a store of value and safe-haven asset.

Calculation

If the spot price of gold is $1,800 per ounce, while the futures price for delivery in six months is $1,750 per ounce, the backwardation would be calculated as follows:

Backwardation = Spot Price - Futures Price

Backwardation = $1,800 - $1,750

Backwardation = $50 per ounce

Outcome

In this example, the backwardation of $50 per ounce indicates that the spot price is $50 higher than the futures price, reflecting heightened demand for immediate physical delivery of gold and expectations of short-term supply constraints.

Limitations

Market Efficiency

While backwardation can provide valuable insights into supply-demand dynamics and market expectations, it is not always a reliable predictor of future price movements. 

Market conditions, speculative activities, and unforeseen events can influence the relationship between spot and futures prices, leading to deviations from backwardation or contango.

Lack of Arbitrage Opportunities

In theory, backwardation should create arbitrage opportunities for market participants to profit from the price differential between spot and futures markets. 

However, factors such as transaction costs, storage costs, financing costs, and delivery logistics may limit the ability to exploit arbitrage opportunities effectively.

Delivery Constraints

Backwardation relies on the assumption that market participants are willing and able to take physical delivery of the underlying commodity at the spot price. 

However, practical considerations such as storage capacity, transportation logistics, and delivery infrastructure may constrain the ability of market participants to engage in physical delivery transactions, particularly for bulky or perishable commodities.

Seasonal Factors

Backwardation and contango dynamics in commodity markets can be influenced by seasonal factors, weather patterns, crop cycles, and other cyclical trends. Seasonal fluctuations in supply and demand may lead to temporary backwardation or contango, which may not necessarily reflect long-term supply-demand fundamentals.

Market Manipulation

In some cases, backwardation or contango may be driven by speculative activities, market manipulation, or regulatory interventions rather than underlying supply-demand dynamics. 

Market participants should exercise caution when interpreting backwardation signals and consider the broader market context and fundamental drivers of price movements.

Conclusion

In conclusion, backwardation is a phenomenon observed in commodity futures markets where the spot price of a commodity exceeds the futures price. Backwardation typically occurs due to short-term supply shortages, heightened demand, or immediate delivery requirements.

While backwardation can provide valuable insights into market sentiment, supply-demand dynamics, and pricing expectations, it is essential to recognize its limitations and exercise caution when interpreting backwardation signals.

Market participants should consider factors such as market efficiency, arbitrage opportunities, delivery constraints, seasonal factors, and the potential for market manipulation when analyzing backwardation trends.

By incorporating a comprehensive understanding of backwardation dynamics into their trading strategies and risk management practices, market participants can navigate commodity markets more effectively and capitalize on investment opportunities while managing potential risks.

References

• Schwartz, A., and Smith, J. E. (2000). "Futures Markets." Journal of Economic Perspectives, 14(1), 139-160.
• Teweles, R. J., and Jones, F. J. (2000). "The Futures Game: Who Wins, Who Loses, and Why." McGraw-Hill Professional.
• Kolb, R. W. (2015). "Futures, Options, and Swaps." John Wiley & Sons.
• Hull, J. C. (2017). "Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives." Pearson.
• Todorova, N., and Bessler, W. (2019). "The Intraday Dynamics of Spot and Future Prices in Agricultural Commodity Markets: An Empirical Study." Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics, 51(1), 57-79.
• Carleton, T., and Wright, J. (2020). "Backwardation in Commodity Futures Markets: Survey and Synthesis." Journal of Commodity Markets, 19, 100130.
• Gorton, G. B., and Rouwenhorst, K. G. (2006). "Facts and Fantasies about Commodity Futures." Financial Analysts Journal, 62(2), 47-68.
• Black, F. (1986). "Noise." Journal of Finance, 41(3), 529-543.
• Fama, E. F. (1991). "Efficient Capital Markets: II." Journal of Finance, 46(5), 1575-1617.
• Working, H. (1960). "Note on the Correlation of First Differences of Averages in a Random Chain." Econometrica, 28(4), 916-918.

FAQ

The main characteristic of a futures market in backwardation is that the futures prices are lower than the spot price.

A market could be in backwardation if there is a short-term increase in demand or decrease in supply of the underlying asset.

Backwardation can benefit commodity producers as they can sell their product at a higher price in the spot market. On the other hand, it can be disadvantageous for consumers who need to buy the commodity in the future.

The opposite of backwardation in futures markets is contango, where the futures prices are higher than the spot price.

Yes, backwardation and contango can coexist in different contracts of the same commodity. This is often due to differences in the time to delivery of the contracts.